Memories of Edgar

Sharing Stories
October 1, 2017 at 11:16 a.m.
Edgar Martínez, courtesy Seattle Mariners
Edgar Martínez, courtesy Seattle Mariners Chris Dubois

Memories of Edgar

The author's sons--young adults today--celebrate another Mariners' win back when Seattle was a baseball town.

On Saturday, Aug. 12, The Seattle Mariners retired Edgar Martinez’s #11. The Mariner’s designated hitter wore the number his entire 18-year career, and no one will wear it here again. It will hang over the left-center field bleachers as a monument to the shining moment when Seattle briefly became a baseball town.

On Saturday, the crowd at Safeco Field cheered wildly, chanting Ed-gaaar, taken back to the wild ride of 1995.

I listened to the ceremony on a transistor radio—our family having decided that the price of a cable bundle that included ROOT Sports wasn’t something we wanted to squeeze into our budget. It was fitting, because growing up in suburban St. Louis, baseball was the soundtrack of my life. In the car, at the kitchen table, beside my father’s striped canvas chair at Sunday afternoon picnics at Babler State Park. I cheered for legends like Bob Gibson, Lou Brock, and Curt Flood.

St. Louis was and is a baseball town. You can talk baseball with anyone, anywhere.

In Seattle, we talk about the weather, or the cost of housing, or who let all these new people in?

But for one wild summer, we all had baseball fever. The Mariners were 13 games out of first place in early August 1995, but then went on a tear. It came down to a one-game tie-breaker with the Los Angeles Angels, which the M’s won 9-1, winning the America League West and making the playoffs for the first time in franchise history.

In the 11th inning of the deciding fifth game of the American League Division Playoffs versus the New York Yankees, Edgar hit the most famous double in Mariners history, immortalized by rapper Macklemore in his tribute to legendary Mariners announcer Dave Niehaus.

Swung on and lined down the left field line for a base hit! Here comes Joey! Here is Junior to third base, they're going to wave him in! The throw to the plate will be . . . Late! The Mariners are going to play for the American League Championship! I don't believe it! It just continues! MY OH MY!

I get goose bumps every time I hear that.

My boys were 5 and 1½ that summer. The baby would lie in his crib at night, kicking up his feet and yelling MY OH MY. The kindergarteners put their heads on their desks, drowsy after watching a late night playoff game. Teachers didn’t mind; they were yawning too. I wore my “Mariners Mom” shirt everywhere; the boys sported matching Mariners shirts and caps and taped Refuse to Lose signs on their bedroom doors.

For a shining moment, anything seemed possible.

Edgar symbolizes that joy, hope, and community. It doesn’t hurt that he’s easy to admire. A dedicated, hardworking, decent guy who has contributed generously to Seattle Children’s Hospital and other civic good causes. He gave an expectedly humble speech—thanking and praising his family, his teammates, his coaches, and the fans.

“Thank you for taking me as one of your own and welcoming me into your homes,” he said. “You were a force that kept me going. I am so grateful. Thank you, thank you, Seattle.”

His stats—including a 68.3 lifetime Wins Above Replacement (WAR)—say he deserves the Hall of Fame. As Seattle Times sportswriter Matt Calkins points out, Edgar is one of just 21 players in major league history with a career batting average over .300, an on-base percentage over .400, and a slugging percentage over .500. Not to mention a seven-time All Star with a 10 for 16 lifetime record against Yankees ace reliever Mariano Rivera.

Still, some people feel designated hitters don’t deserve to be in the Hall of Fame. In January, on his eighth ballot, Edgar got 58.6 percent of the vote. He has two more chances to get the required 75 percent. Saturday showed that he’ll always be top of the ballot in our hearts.

It’s been 16 years now since the M’s have been in the playoffs, and they’re one of only two teams in the MLB not ever to appear in the World Series.

Here in Seattle, we’re wearing our Seahawks blue on Fridays and have gone back to talking about the weather and how traffic gets worse and worse with all these new folks moving in.

After the ceremony honoring Edgar, the M’s took the field and lost 6-3 to the Oakland A’s, slipping a game out of the second wildcard spot. Meanwhile, as the ESPN app on my iPad informed me, the Cardinals won their eighth straight and moved into a tie for first in the National League East.

Miss you, Edgar! And go Cards!

© 2017 Christine Dubois

Christine Dubois is a widely published freelance writer, writing coach, and baseball fan who lives in Bothell. Visit her at

SHARING STORIES is a weekly column for and about the 50 plus crowd living in the Puget Sound region. Send your stories and photos to Tell local or personal stories; discuss concerns around aging and other issues; share solutions, good luck, and reasons to celebrate; poems are fine too. Pieces may be edited or excerpted. We reserve the right to select among pieces. Photos are always a plus and a one-sentence bio is requested (where you live, maybe age or career, retired status, etc.).

SHARING STORIES is featured on, the website for Northwest Prime Time, a monthly publication for baby boomers, seniors, retirees, and those contemplating retirement. The newspaper can be found in the greater Seattle area and other Puget Sound locations. For more information, call 206-824-8600 or visit To find other SHARING STORIES articles on this website type "sharing stories" in the search function above.

Share this story!