To Marry or Not?

Magic at Midlife: Your Relationship Roadmap for Romance After 40
August 25, 2014 at 6:00 a.m.
Northwest authors Jennifer Y. Levy-Peck, PhD, a psychologist, and her husband Charles Peck are write a weekly column on midlife relationships.  They are working on a new book, "Magic at Midlife: Your Relationship Roadmap for Romance After 40."
Northwest authors Jennifer Y. Levy-Peck, PhD, a psychologist, and her husband Charles Peck are write a weekly column on midlife relationships. They are working on a new book, "Magic at Midlife: Your Relationship Roadmap for Romance After 40."

...by Jennifer Y. Levy-Peck, PhD and Charles Peck

When Jennifer started living with her first husband in the 1970s (before they got married), she lied to her grandmother and said she had a female roommate, because Grammy certainly would not have approved of “living in sin.” Nowadays, grandma and grandpa are just as likely as young folks to be cohabiting without being married. In fact, according to the U.S. Census Bureau, the number of cohabiting couples age 50 or older more than doubled between 2000 and 2010.

There are many practical and emotional considerations involved in the decision to marry or not. On the practical side, scores of seniors choose to stay single because of financial concerns. For example, a person who is receiving Social Security or a pension based on a former spouse’s employment may be worse off after remarriage. Parents whose kids are still in college may be concerned because financial aid will be based on household income, including that of the new spouse. There are certain tax benefits to being single. In addition, people with children from a former relationship may be concerned about financial conflicts between their kids and their new spouse.

On the emotional side, marriage may have lost its luster after a bad experience in the past. Some older couples just don’t see the point – they are not going to have children together, after all, and getting married just doesn’t matter in the same way it did when they were younger. The hassle and expense of a wedding may not appeal, and many older couples really don’t care what others think about their unwed state. Marriage itself may be distasteful to those who see it as an extension of patriarchy or an oppressive relationship. And then, of course, there is still a huge contingent of people in same-sex relationships who don’t have the choice because they live in states that have not yet embraced marriage equality.

On the other hand, many seniors do marry or remarry, and find it to be a meaningful acknowledgement of their partnership. They like being able to say, “my husband,” or “my wife.” They prefer to have formal bonds set through marriage, rather than having to draft individualized legal documents with an attorney just to protect their financial wishes or other arrangements. Regardless of age, some of us still like the idea of proclaiming commitment through marriage.

The bottom line is that each person should carefully consider the financial and emotional consequences of marrying vs. living together, have a frank conversation with his or her partner, and consult an attorney or financial advisor if needed. And don’t lie to your grandchildren if you decide to “live in sin”!

Northwest authors Jennifer Y. Levy-Peck, PhD, a psychologist, and her husband Charles Peck are write a weekly column on midlife relationships. They are working on a new book, "Magic at Midlife: Your Relationship Roadmap for Romance After 40."

Previous Magic at Midlife Columns:

Conversations About Death for Midlife Couples

The Couple That Laughs Together, Stays Together

Vacation Time! Leave Your Baggage at Home

Your Place or Mine? Moving In Together

How to Help Your Partner Calm Down

Creating Shared Goals

Having the “Senior Safer Sex” Conversation

Planning Your Wedding (for Mature Couples)

Too Young or Too Old to be Your Partner?

Who Pays for What on a Date

Starting a New Relationship Before Your Kids Are Grown

Why You Need a Relationship Roadmap

Living with Pets and a New Partner

Exploring New Roles

Rowing Through Life Together

Let’ Talk About Sex

Helping Your Adult Children Accept Your New Partner

In Sickness and In Health

Step-Grandparenting Can Be Grand

Enjoy Life Together

Online Dating for the Older Set

Enjoying the Single Life

True Love

Sex in Midlife Relationships: Complicated but Wonderful!

Upgrade Your Communication Skills

Latest Edition

View and download this publication.

Latest Stories


60,000 Asahel Curtis Images Being Preserved for the Public
Most people in Washington have probably seen an Asahel Curtis photograph, whether or not they recognized it as his work

A veggie family tree: Broccoli brothers, cabbage cousins and more
This veggie family is high in vitamin C, A and K, and has lots of fiber

New Affordable Senior Housing Community Opens in Seattle
The grand opening celebration of the new community, Northaven West, was marked with a picnic and music by the West Seattle Band

Harvest, Store and Preserve Herbs from the Garden
Keep enjoying your homegrown herbs all year round

Alternatives to Showing Your Social Security Card
SSA has taken steps to offer alternate options to reduce the occasions when our customers would need to apply for a replacement card